Best Cozy Mystery in 2022

How to Write a Cozy Mystery

If you are planning to write a Cozy Mystery, there are several factors you need to take into account. These include the setting, the characters, the Red herrings, and the Paranormal elements. Here are some suggestions to make your mystery a success. You can also find some tips for writing an enjoyable cozie by reading the following articles. Moreover, if you have any doubts about how to write a Cozy Mystery, feel free to ask the authors for assistance.


The protagonist in a cozy mystery novel is a low-key amateur sleuth who may be unqualified to run his own detective agency but falls into it by accident. The main character must pose an agreeable puzzle and offer every clue along the way. It is also important to include enough red herrings to keep the reader guessing. A cozy mystery has a cast of characters that range from eccentric to exasperating.

A typical cozy mystery book features a good-guy main character who uncovers the culprit's identity. The main character may be narrated in the first person or third person. The protagonist should be likable and not a heroin addict. It is a good idea to include a few recurring supporting characters, such as a local cop or a wealthy woman. The sleuth should also be a sympathetic character who is not prone to violence or drugs.

While the protagonist in a cozy mystery novel may be the central character of the book, the heroine should not be terribly missed. In many cozy mysteries, the victim is a wealthy uncle who is not particularly vulnerable. But a murder is inevitable because the plot requires it. The criminal in a cozy mystery novel usually has a human quality and a good reason for doing what he or she does. While murder is a necessary evil, the violence should be contained within the story's lines.


A cozy mystery usually takes place in a small town or village where the inhabitants know each other and are generally very likeable. The amateur sleuth is also often likable and can use gossip to her advantage. In addition, a cozy mystery usually features a knowledgeable character who helps her solve the mystery. As long as this character does not appear to be a perfect match for her protagonist, she can easily turn the reader off.

The most common setting for a cozy mystery is a small town or village, but there are also some that are set in big cities. In the latter case, the authors tend to use a neighborhood that resembles a small town. Classic settings for cozy mysteries include St. Mary's Mead and Cabot Cove. Whether a town is rural or urban, the setting is critical in creating the feel of a small town mystery.

Cuddle mysteries are full of humour. Humour does not need to be over-the-top. However, it is important that the humour remains mild and does not upset the agreeable tone of the book. If humour is naturally occurring in the story, the writer should not be afraid to include it. A cozy mystery can be as dark as it is humorous. The goal is to create a story with a balance between dark and light elements.

Red herrings

A red herring is a non-existent item that a person would mistake for a real one. Unlike a real object, a red herring is not intended to be the main source of information. Rather, it serves to make the suspects three-dimensional. However, red herrings are not always helpful to the reader. They may lead to false leads and divert attention from real clues.

A red herring is a ploy to distract the reader from a central theme or character in a cozy mystery. The author of the book uses a red herring to make the reader wonder if the murderer is a real person, or if the character is merely acting as a distraction. Elizabeth George distinguishes between red herrings and false clues. In a red herring, a character in the book uses an unrelated item to confuse the reader.

A red herring in a cozy mystery may be a humorous ploy created by the amateur detective. The author may also include an ulterior motive for the murder, such as a romantic interest, in the story. However, the author should always keep in mind that a mystery has many suspects. A variety of suspects keeps the mystery moving forward. This makes it easier for the reader to buy into the characters.

Paranormal elements

A cozy mystery is a book that combines the mystery of solving a crime with elements of magic and the paranormal. Paranormal elements can take the form of ghosts, werewolves, vampires, witches, and other supernatural creatures. The protagonist may be a psychic, witch, or even a werewolf. He or she may even encounter a ghost, or even befriend one! Whatever the case, a paranormal element will play a significant role in the plot.

Most cozy mystery series do not include any supernatural elements, though you can find one that does. Kyra Davis's Sophie Katz Murder Mysteries are an excellent example of a paranormal cozy mystery. While the main protagonist is an American, she is the author of the longest-running paranormal cozy mystery series. The protagonist, Lori Sheppard, is in love with a beautiful Victorian house and wants to buy it regardless of its drawbacks. In the process, she is forced to deal with a ghost and her ex, a real estate agent.

Although these mysteries are grounded in reality, there is room for a little bit of the paranormal in them. For example, a poisoned chocolate chip cookie might be a great starting point for a cozy mystery, but as the story progresses, the author can include details of a mysterious tree that appears on the scene. Paranormal elements aren't necessary, but they can help set the book apart from the rest. However, they should not be overdone.

Character flaws

Writers of cozy mysteries should be particularly careful with their character flaws, because a typical cozy heroine tends to be overweight, disorganized, and prone to exaggeration. They should avoid putting outright evil characters, but they must make them likable and believable enough for readers to suspend disbelief. For example, a heroine in a cozy mystery might be overweight or disorganized, and she might be klutzy. If that's the case, don't forget to include character flaws as part of the heroine's personality.

In a cozy mystery, a character flaw can be either major or minor. The flaws should affect the dialogue between characters, their reaction to events, and their overall development. Character flaws are an excellent way to create an emotional connection between the reader and your protagonist. Moreover, they can help create tension and make readers empathize with the protagonist. However, don't forget to include minor character flaws.

A cozy mystery protagonist is usually an amateur sleuth, with access to information and a rotating cast of suspects. Popular professions include teacher, newspaper reporter, cafe/bakery owner, librarian, and librarian. A protagonist is generally female and either millennial or octogenarian. Cozy mysteries do not typically feature any violence or risk harming children. You can even find characters with flaws in a thriller, though they are less common than in a cozy mystery.

Character's relationship with law enforcement

A cozy mystery is a detective thriller without violence. The mystery genre originated with Agatha Christie, who began the cozy tradition. Her novels, which were written in the 1960s and 1970s, usually featured a middle-aged detective in a new locale who is assigned to find a missing person. Each book also features a familiar victim and involves a family member who helps with the investigation.

Because these mysteries do not have a hard-boiled edge, the characters should still have a strong sense of community. A cozy mystery character should have a strong connection to the local law enforcement organization and have some sort of psychological impact on the protagonist. The author should also create a world large enough to allow for a character's offstage life to play a part in the character's downfall and the motive of the killer.

While most cozies involve amateur detectives, police officers and private investigators can also write cozies. To avoid causing confusion in the reader, authors can write about real investigators. However, it's important to remember that a cozy reader will not be as receptive to mixed genres, such as SF-Mysteries. However, if the reader likes the concept, cozy writers can take it a step further by introducing characters from another genre.

Andrea Lopez

International student since the age of fifteen. Varied cultural awareness and broad perspective of the academic world through several experiences abroad: Spain, Ireland, the UK, Guatemala, and Japan. Organised, highly adaptable, impeccable customer service skills and excellent rapport building abilities.

📧Email | 📘 LinkedIn